Sunday, October 11, 2009

Any comments on this poem? Thank you.?

Like is Fiction





Pedaling down a familiar street


on a red bmx bike,


wearing a blue summer dress,


I brake hard.


I fly over the top of that concrete wall and


pick a pomegranate for you because


I like you.


We eat it, pucker our lips, squint our eyes


and feel mischievous.


And I've stained my blue summer dress.

Any comments on this poem? Thank you.?
Hi Sara, I like this. I really do. Unlike some of your other reviews I don't feel this is a short story just a poem that could use some trimming and thought to refine what you are saying. You may want to pare it down a bit. Here are few comments.





First image (lines 1-2): Pedaling is good it keeps the poem from feeling static. "familiar street"--you could probably come up with something more evocative here, something that engages the senses a little more. The red bmx bike is a nice specific detail.





Second image (line 3): I like the blue summer dress. I like that you are introducing colors into my mind first red now blue. I'm not crazy about "wearing". It tells us you're clothed but that's all it gives us. Maybe something to show the speed of the bikes affect on the dress. I love that you use few words in the poem, but it does mean you have to maximize the ones you do use).





Line 4: fine, though you may want to put an image in as to why you had to brake hard. It could be short (i.e., something with a cat, pothole, car, etc) just something to fix the scene more clearly in the reader's mind.





Line 5: You could remove "I" here. You could also remove "the top of".





Line 6-7: A little random here, but I like it. You could eliminate "for you"





Line 8: Maybe something like "Juices roll down, lips pucker, our eyes squint"





Line 9: You could probably just go with "mischievous" here.





Line 10: You could drop the "and" here.





That was a quick initial pass. I am not trying to rewrite your poem at all just give you some feedback. I appreciated the critique you gave to me--I wanted to return the favor (which isn't painful at all if I enjoy the poem--Which I did).





You have a very clean, original writing style.





Thanks for sharing.
Reply:It seems to be the beginning of a short story.


And what made you use the word, "pomegranate"? Was that your way of being different?


Try to use the word "love" instead of "like" when you write poetry.


Practice makes perfect, so keep trying and I'm sure your poems will get better and better.
Reply:nice poem keep creating such trash!!!!
Reply:its alright.
Reply:complete crap...not poetry!
Reply:hmm, a bit cranky....
Reply:Try something that rhyme or would encourage the reader to use their imagination. Try also reading real poem
Reply:Try something more moving, romantic, extraordinary. This one is just down to earth. Nice trying anyway :))
Reply:i think that it is story but not a poem
Reply:who gets a nickel bag anymore? lol
Reply:Thanks for sharing your poem. It seems like some people commenting want to battle. Continue inking pages with words that capture attention and tell a story.
Reply:I like this poem. I can see a story within the poem possibly coming from a child's perspective b/c of the "pucker our lips, squint our eyes" bit and the "I like you". I thought this entire poem was unusual, and not just b/c you mentioned the fruit "pomegranate", which I totally get b/c it's perfect for leading us into "the kiss?", right? or did they steal that pomegranate?


Good job. Continue writing.



skin care product

No comments:

Post a Comment

 


pomegranate © 2008. Design by: Pocket Web Hosting